The origins of this haunting are shrouded in mystery, but it's said that the pirates in question met a grisly end at the hands of the castle's former occupants. Over the years, numerous people have reported seeing the ghostly ship and its crew, with some even claiming to have caught glimpses of the treasure being unloaded. While the details of the haunting are sketchy, the sheer number of witness accounts lends credence to the idea that something unusual is indeed occurring at Castle Dunanore.

The story behind the White Lady on Horseback dates back to a time when the roads around Kilpatrick were little more than dirt tracks. It's believed she was riding her horse somewhere north of the village when it suddenly bolted, throwing her into the quarry. The incident was fatal, and it's thought that her spirit has been trapped here ever since. While there's no concrete evidence to support the claim, multiple witnesses have come forward to describe the apparition, which is always seen on moonlit nights. Some have even reported hearing the sound of horse's hooves, which seems to come from nowhere and everywhere at the same time.